« Stryker Questions Remain | Main | Give 'em the VIP Treatment »

Bookmark and Share

Oct 12, 2005

Spinning the V-22

Some of POGO's concerns about the V-22 Osprey tilt-rotor aircraft found their way in Bob Cox's story in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram today.  But what Cox really added was some important context.  The military and contractors positively spin the V-22 by comparing it to Vietnam-era aircraft, rather than modern helicopters:

The [V-22] testing report (pdf) contains data on how far the Osprey flew, how fast, and how well, in performing various missions. All comparisons are made to the Marines’ Vietnam-era CH-46 helicopters, rather than more modern helicopters, which critics say can perform most of the same missions as well as the Osprey at far lower cost [ed's note: the V-22 price tag is currently $72 million per aircraft according to Cox's story; some quick division using a recent Selected Acquisition Report's yields a per unit price of $110 million, a price that likely factors in sunk R&D costs].

Cox also mentions the possibility of a behind the scenes battle between the Pentagon's leadership, quasi-independent testers and contractors over the writing of the V-22 report:

[Philip Coyle, former chief weapons tester at the Pentagon] said the language of the [V-22] report reflects the tension between the testing office and the military, and sometimes between members of the test team itself.

The testing office and the military contract with a quasi-independent agency, the Institute for Defense Analysis, for technical analysis and guidance. There have historically been strong disagreements between the weapons testing experts and the military over the conduct and outcomes of tests.

If there have been disagreements, what were they over and who won?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c68bf53ef00d8345b1f7869e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Spinning the V-22:

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

» POGO Takes Aim At V-22 Osprey from Defense Industry Daily
V-22 Osprey The Project On Government Oversight (POGO) has been a champion of some defense programs (vid. the A-10), an opponent of others that it believes to be wasteful and/or ineffective, and an opponent willing to reconsider on still other... [Read More]

Comments

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

POGO Blog

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Blogroll